Just one of those weeks, things conspire to make it a time of thought and reflection. Work overflowing with problems, unsettled elsewhere. The game is as enticing as always, it’s just that sometimes the mind dallies along the way.
‘Glory glory hallelujah’ rolling out from the east upper (so it seemed) threw me. I had a vision of the East Stand, old school, battle hardened veterans but never weary of good football, the old fashioned song had to return. That was ours once, you know. No one else dared sing it. No ‘glory glory Man Utd’, just us. Time for a comeback.
Thoughts too of John White, a hero of a bygone age brought to life in a terrific book ‘The Ghost of White Hart Lane’ by his son Rob and Julie Welch, reviewed here last week. Frail, deceptively influential, superb passer of the ball, tireless in his energy and capacity to support team-mates. Sounds familiar? Surely his spirit lives in another Tottenham great, Luka Modric, a peerless display of the midfield art. Gliding over the turf, he’s involved in a scuffling tackle to regain possession, lays it off, your eyes stick with the ball yet suddenly a few moments later, he’s there, 40 or 50 yards, in attack now, scheming, touching it on, looking for the shot. String theory. Particle physics. There’s an idea that the fundamental particles that make up all matter, some of them have a property of being in two places at once. Luka’s made up entirely of those.
It’s odd how you can be alone with your thoughts amidst the bedlam of a London derby. Like the mascot. No older than 4, he stands for the minute’s silence. 36,000 thousand people, still in mournful respect, he starts to practice his moves. The kick, a stretch forward, like a slow motion robot. Delightful, bless him, totally oblivious to the world outside his imagination.
Back to reality with a bang. Harry’s imagination has been working overtime in the break since our last game. The climax of the season, playing a relegation threatened team, totally new formation. That’s the thing with Harry: even after all this time I can’t quite figure out if he’s brave or barmy. Sure I admire him for trying something new, a different way to both utilise to the full the talent in the squad and do something about our lack of goals, but now, at a time like this, when we needed a win against a team down the bottom, not now, surely.
Let’s start, as always, in centre midfield. Redknapp’s selection of Sandro on the face of it does not seem too surprising, given his masterful performance over two legs against Milan. However, he’s been uncomfortable for the most part in the league, taking time to adjust to the pace and particularly the pressure of the Premier League. Teams have sussed this, pressing him as soon as he gains possession even if it meant pushing a man right out of midfield to do so.
On the basis of this game, Sandro has passed another milestone in his development towards what I believe will be a highly successful career. He proved he’s adapted. Strong in defence, fearless in the tackle with the stamina and awareness of a genuine defensive midfielder. Luka was outstanding: he’s a truly wonderful footballer, a privilege to see him play in our colours. As good at this age as any since Gazza and if he keeps this up, he’ll become one of the great Spurs midfielders of the last 30 or 40 years.
The change was of course Defoe up front on his own with Rafa allowed even more freedom than usual to rome, actually make that, allowed less freedom because he was told to drop deep and pick up the ball. Advantage: we have an extra body in midfield, that allows Bale and Lennon, wide men key to our attacking formation, more leeway to get wide and stay there, covers the space against opponents also playing 5 in the middle with a strong middle three of Hitzlsburger, the excellent Parker and Noble.
Disadvantage: he’s not up front. Where we need goals. Where JD is isolated. Can’t be in two places at once, unless you’re a subatomic particle (theory unproven) or Luka Modric (fact).
Defoe up front on his own was an odd one, because although his positional play and movement is much improved this season, there’s precious little evidence to show that he functions well in this role. If anything, he’s the classic ‘little man’ in the bigman/little man partnership, which in the modern game has become one striker playing off another. He needs someone alongside him to put him in.
Also, Bale and Lennon are there to provide the crosses, but to whom? On Saturday, most of the time, to no one. With no target in the middle, their effectiveness is diminished regardless of the opposition’s tactics, and on Saturday Bridge handled Lennon very well. We looked brighter when Pav came on, went to 4-4-2 and the Whammers were tired. He had space to do that thing he does, you know, knocks it a metre in front of him, moves onto the ball and wangs it, like the goal he scored against Chelsea.
JD as lone striker smacks of desperation rather than sound tactical planning. It may be new but underlying it is the same old problem – none of our three strikers are good enough at the highest level.
Rafa has been on the end of some hefty criticism around some of the boards and sites. Already people are saying he’s a luxury, that he doesn’t fit in. Mine is only the ‘hefty’ bit: he needs to shed a few pounds, it seems to me, and to get fully fit again so he can trust his legs and lungs for 90 minutes.
The thing about Rafa coming deep is not just about what he does, it’s what everyone else does in response. Modric was able to push on past him, as was Bale. Lennon should have varied his position when he did not have the ball, should have got in the box more. This movement has to be part of the system if this is how we’re going to play. Rafa deep gives us more options but only if other players not only get past him into the box but have the ability to do some damage once they get there. This goes for Rafa himself: he’s got to be more mobile with the stamina to last the game, including some lung busting runs to get right into danger areas. If this is the way to go, we need to have that commitment and awareness from other players to be flexible and to move well.
Certainly it produced some excellent flowing football. Our movement was a joy to behold at times, we always had a spare man, the width and a series of long crossfield balls from deep meant an expansive game and we held onto possession well for three quarters of the game, the exception being the first twenty minutes of the second half where our opponents not only took the game to us, they could so easily have scored a goal that might have proved to be the winner.
No punch up front to finish, all our good work put to waste. And yet the chances were there. Defoe missed three good ones and a couple more. I thought he had the measure of the defence when he twice early on got to the near post first, in front of his marker. Showed he was sharp and thinking about the game, but there was no sharpness when the easier opportunities came his way. Not the most emotionally intelligent of individuals, scoring against his old team probably meant too much, which got in the way of his instincts.
Whatever, no use Harry getting ratty with the MOTD interviewer. Three games against teams we could have beaten, two points. 4th is receding as fast and as far as my hairline. I liked the formation, with the proviso that VDV uses this break to return to fitness I’d like to see it again sometime, maybe with Pav up front, but then again…I know, none of them are quite reliable enough. It makes good use of Rafa and Luka, gives Bale the chance to get in the box and if JD had taken just one of those opportunities… but it requires polishing, so leave it for now, or for when we are three up away from home, certainly back to 4-4-2 against Wigan.
10 thoughts on “Spurs: Reflections On A Goalless Draw and Particle Physics (Eat Your Heart Out, Brian Cox)”
I am beginning to see the point being made by some, that the involvement of VDV has a required a major rethinking of our tactics which means that we have to think in terms of “perm two from three” with Crouch, JD and VDV. It seems clear that VDV and JD does not work very well, especially where we reduce our attacking options by having one or even two DM’s.
One possible suggestion is to change to 3-5-2, or even 3-2-3-2, as I think our lack of goals this season has been due to the number of times we have played with only one striker up front. Crouch hasn’t got the ability to play like an old fashioned CF, and Defoe is too limited in the air, so effectively, they need each other up front.
VDV deep could give others freedom to play and to attack. I like the formation but JD is not the man to have as the lone striker.
3-5-2 is tempting, especially as we have potential wing backs plus, if they are fit, our many centre halves. Problem is, opponents can expose the defence if they get behind the wingbacks. The defence shifts wide, leaving too much space. Look at the damage Blackpool did by shifting the ball around wide and quickly.
The modern game requires movement, intelligence and flexibility, rather than set rigid positions and patterns. There’s also a greater onus on strikers to score a decent percentage, as chances may be fewer, with midfielders adding to the tally.
There was nothing wrong with the tactics . Defoe failed to put away sitters. Plain and simple
Considering he’s not fully fit, in games like this we should just go back to more traditional methods. Two upfront. There’s enough offensive outlets via Modric, Bale and Lennon to carve up and create than to rely on vdV who seemed to be far too deep for his own good on Saturday.
Nice article. I agree with you that this formations with VDV comming deep needs working on. IMO, on saturday only Luka responded accordingly by getting further up the pitch and having a few dangerous shoots. Bale and Lennon were little passive in their movement (always staying wide). Still we produced some of the wonderfull football this way, so it might work.
Thanks Dali, and not surreal in the slightest. On reflection I should have been stronger against people on the net and on the messageboards who were having a go at Harry and VDV. This could work and we played some brilliant stuff. As another comment says – we made the chances, JD missed them, that’s all there is to be said. We don’t the right striker for this formation, however, to really make it work under pressure.
have not read yet but will. Fyi, i dont think this appeared on newsnow, im here as i like your articles and have bookmarked the site. This site deserves to be viewed by more. Pls have a word with NN
Thanks ubs, sincerely appreciated. I agree – TOMM does indeed deserve to be viewed more people….
…it isn’t and won’t be but I toddle along. It’s wonderful and humbling that fans make the effort to find the site, that genuinely means a lot. From the site stats it’s clear a small but select group do now seek it out regularly, and this means a lot to me. At the moment I’m pushed for time at home and at work, so pieces may appear later that I would wish, like this one for instance, but the positive comments keep me going.
This piece did appear on NN. The non-appearance on NN of the Grit and Glory piece that I referred to in ‘Testing’ was due to the use of a swear word, as Spooky points on in the comments. NN contacted me about it to explain, which was lovely of them because they have hundreds of pieces a day just on the Spurs section. There was no problem per se with my article or the blog but since they received complaints about swearing on NN, rightly they have introduced a swear filter.
You may not have noticed this or any other piece on there because often they quickly slip from the first page or two – the professional sites push out lots of stuff about Spurs, especially when we are doing well, in order to get the hits and the advertising revenue. I’ve decided not to have advertising so I can just do what I want to. Even if no one reads it.
Great writing Alan, thoroughly enjoy your pieces and always look forward to reading them. Agree with you totally on Modric, an absolute joy to watch and would grace any team. I’m also enjoying ‘the Ghost of White Hart Lane’ and, though John White was also before my time, the comparison with Modric seems very apt.
Fantastic web site. A lot of useful information here. I’m sending it to several buddies ans also sharing in delicious. And certainly, thank you to your sweat!